Superintendent Evaluation

Level: AccompanyingDescriptor Code:Rescinds
Policy
B-School Board Operations
Procedure:
BBDA March 18, 2026
Descriptor Term:Effective Date:Date Last Reviewed
Superintendent EvaluationSeptember 24, 2026 September 24, 2026
 


Purpose

The Gwinnett County Board of Education (“Board”) shall evaluate the Superintendent annually through a fair, collaborative, and evidence-based process in which the Board and Superintendent mutually agree, in advance, on the evaluation goals, criteria, timeline, evidence, and format . The purpose of the Superintendent evaluation is to provide feedback, recognize accomplishments, support professional growth, and ensure progress toward the district's goals.

Evaluation Components

The Superintendent’s annual evaluation shall be primarily based on performance goals that are specific, measurable, achievable, timebound, and established by mutual agreement of the Board and Superintendent in alignment with the district’s strategic plan and the Superintendent’s employment contract. The performance goals shall include, but not be limited to, measurement of systemwide academic and financial performance with academic measures disaggregated by student subgroups reported by the state accountability system.

The Board’s annual evaluation process shall specifically define the methodology for how the Board will determine whether the Superintendent is meeting the minimum expectations of their employment contract.

Evaluation Process

The period of evaluation shall be the school / fiscal year beginning July 1st and ending June 30th. The annual evaluation of the Superintendent for the prior school year shall be finalized no later than December 31st of each year to allow the necessary time to compile summative data for the prior school year.

The Board and Superintendent shall establish annual performance goals prior to August 31st, through a documented process of mutual agreement. If the Board and Superintendent have not reached mutual agreement by August 31st, the parties shall continue to negotiate in good faith, and the Board shall be authorized to establish the annual performance goals until new goals are mutually established.

The Board Chair or his/her designee is responsible for coordinating and conducting the evaluation process according to the timelines and processes established by this policy. Each board member is expected to participate in the evaluation process, and the feedback of each member shall be equally considered in the final evaluation.

The Board shall conduct at least one mid-year informal evaluation conference with the Superintendent to include a self-assessment by the Superintendent, a review of progress toward each annual performance goal, identification of any necessary mid-course adjustments, and mutual agreement on the supports the Superintendent will need from the Board to ensure successful attainment of those goals.

The Superintendent shall complete and submit a self-evaluation prior to the Board’s final evaluation conference. The self-evaluation shall address progress toward each annual performance goal, evidence of growth and development across multiple indicators, and reflections on opportunities for continued improvement. The self-evaluation shall be considered alongside the Board’s evidence in formulating the final evaluation rating.

The Superintendent and Board Chair shall sign the final evaluation summary report. Copies of the final report shall be given to the Superintendent and placed in the Superintendent's personnel file.

Employment Contract

The Superintendent’s employment contract shall refer to a process for establishing annual performance goals by mutual agreement of the Board and Superintendent that serve as the primary basis of evaluation, in alignment with this policy.